How to Shift from Etsy to a Standalone Site as an Emerging eCommerce Entrepreneur

You started an online store on Etsy and spent time growing an audience and a list of repeat customers. Now, you should probably shift your frequent clients to an independent platform, where you maintain control.

However, moving from Etsy to a standalone site requires some work and an understanding of the differences. Your audience may also have some preferences about where they shop. Here are the things to keep in mind as you make the transition.

1. Set Goals

Consider the specific goals you want to achieve by opening a separate site. Some reasons include:

  • Expanding to customers outside a single platform
  • Maintaining complete control over your business
  • Preparing for any potential changes by Etsy that might negatively impact your business
  • Gaining more customization options

Setting up a dedicated site costs money. By setting specific goals that you keep in mind, you can keep the new website within your budget while ensuring your site meets your unique needs.

2. Prepare for Growth

As your business grows, you may have times when traffic spikes — for example, research indicates that around 66% of people will increase their online shopping during the holidays. Pay attention to when your busiest seasons are and when you sell the most. Make sure your new website can handle the increased bandwidth during those times.

  • Ask about bandwidth rules and charges for going over
  • Consider what new products might pay your website costs and bring more sales
  • Know your audience and where to teach them

Ideally, you’ll launch new marketing campaigns alongside your new standalone site.

3. Secure Domain Name

Whether you use a dedicated server or put your store on a platform such as Squarespace, Wix or Shopify, you’ll need a domain name to send customers to. For e-commerce sites in the U.S., a .com domain is your best bet. People recognize it as a commercial site and are comfortable with the extension.

  • Find a reasonable domain name registrar. You can use GoDaddy or WordPress Domains, for example. Be sure they are reputable, as you don’t want to lose your domain.
  • Search for a name yet to be used to brand your store.
  • Find one that is easy to spell and remember. The harder you make the name, the more likely someone will mess up typing it and never make it to your storefront.

Most registrars ask where to point the name. For now, secure the domain. You can worry about fixing nameservers later. The website hosting provider will likely have instructions on how to make the changes easily when you’re ready.

4. Choose the Right Platform

E-commerce generates around $5.7 trillion per year and is growing. Where you place your standalone website may be as important as its name. You want a reliable hosting provider with high uptime statistics.

If designing the site yourself, you need something easy to use or that your web designer understands. While not an exhaustive list, some options include:

  • Shopify
  • Wix
  • Squarespace
  • WordPress hosting through any web host provider
  • Zyro

For the most control, go with a shared hosting plan. You can upgrade to a dedicated hosting plan as you grow. For a drag-and-drop solution, choose a platform geared toward online sellers.

5. Migrate Your Store

Once you set up your site, start migrating products to your new store. The fastest way to migrate information is to download your store’s data and upload it to the new platform. Each will have a different process. To download a CSV file from Etsy:

  • Log in to your store account and go to “Store Manager.”
  • Navigate to Settings > Options > Download Data.
  • Indicate you want a CSV file.

The file will contain information on your active listings, which you can upload to your new platform. Double-check all information to ensure everything copied correctly.

Should You Leave Your Etsy Store Up?

Since Etsy charges per listing, whether your item sells or not, you may wonder if you should keep your Etsy store even after creating a new website. It depends. Look at where your traffic comes from. If most of the purchases are from your private marketing and mailing list, you could delete your listings. However, if the majority of your traffic comes from Etsy searches, you will want to leave your store active until your website sales surpass your Etsy sales.

You can also list items in multiple places, including Etsy, eBay and Mercari, as well as on your website. As long as you make sales and profit, you’ll benefit from each platform’s marketing.

Embarking on a project related to our latest post "How to Shift from Etsy to a Standalone Site as an Emerging eCommerce Entrepreneur"?

Leverage our years of experience in websites, design and digital marketing. We are here to help you navigate the complexities of crafting a seamless digital experience. To discuss your specific needs and goals, please fill out the contact form below and let us answer your questions and bring your vision to life.